Top Murder and Mayhem True Crime Stories

The best Murder & Mayhem True Accounts includes If You Tell: A True Story, Chaos: The O'Neill & Piepenbring Audiobook, Framed: True Stories of Wrongful Convictions and many others as mentioned below.

1

If You Tell: A True Story

  • A true story of survival and resilience.
  • #1 bestselling author Gregg Olsen narrates.
  • Three sisters escape a mother's horrific abuse.
  • Unbreakable bond forged through unimaginable trauma.
  • Reveals dark family secrets and multiple murders.
  • A harrowing journey towards freedom and justice.
  • A testament to sisterhood and empowerment.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $4.99
2

Chaos: The O'Neill & Piepenbring Audiobook

  • Investigative journalist unveils shocking Manson revelations.
  • Explores FBI's hidden role in Manson murders.
  • Decades of research and interviews conducted.
  • Reassesses infamous case in American history.
  • Uncovers potential cover-ups and legal misconduct.
  • Questions surrounding Manson's Hollywood connections revealed.
  • Includes exclusive documents from LAPD and CIA.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $26.61
3

Framed: True Stories of Wrongful Convictions

  • #1 New York Times Bestseller
  • John Grisham's first nonfiction work since The Innocent Man
  • Ten true stories of wrongful convictions
  • Collaboration with Jim McCloskey, innocence movement leader
  • Explores flaws in the criminal justice system
  • Impeccably researched with suspenseful storytelling
  • Includes downloadable PDF with sources and acknowledgments
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $19.69
4

The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck and Mutiny

  • Thrilling true story of survival and mutiny.
  • Explores the depths of human behavior under duress.
  • Epic tale of shipwreck and desperate struggle.
  • A riveting narrative by bestselling author David Grann.
  • Unfolds during a British imperial mission in 1740.
  • Engaging account of a dramatic court-martial.
  • Highlights the complexities of loyalty and treachery.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $17.72
5

If You Tell by Gregg Olsen (Audiobook)

  • Shocking true-crime story of survival and resilience.
  • Unbreakable bond of three sisters against evil.
  • A #1 bestseller across major charts.
  • 2021 Audie Award Nominee for Best Nonfiction Audiobook.
  • Details unimaginable abuse and degradation by their mother.
  • Empowering tale of courage and justice.
  • Harrowing yet heartwarming survivor's journey.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $21.88
6

The Wager: A Saga of Shipwreck and Mutiny

  • Page-turning story of survival and betrayal.
  • Reveals shocking truths of maritime imperialism.
  • Captivating narrative by bestselling author David Grann.
  • Explores human behavior under extreme conditions.
  • A thrilling court martial with life-or-death stakes.
  • Highlights the clash between heroism and mutiny.
  • A masterful blend of history and adventure.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.06
7

American Black Widow: True Story of a Preacher's Killer

  • True story of a preacher's wife turned killer.
  • Engaging narrative by bestselling author Gregg Olsen.
  • Two husbands' mysterious deaths raise suspicions.
  • Set in the sleepy town of Rocky Ford.
  • Explores themes of greed, sex, and murder.
  • A gripping read for true crime enthusiasts.
  • Originally published as Confessions of an American Black Widow.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $0.99
  • Color: Reverend Mike Fuller
8

The Devil in the White City (Audiobook Edition)

  • True tale of the 1893 World's Fair.
  • Focus on serial killer Henry H. Holmes.
  • Architect Daniel Hudson Burnham’s monumental achievements.
  • Contrast between beauty and horror at the fair.
  • Real-life historical characters enhance the narrative.
  • Engaging storytelling by Erik Larson.
  • A chilling exploration of ambition and madness.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $19.69
9

Killers of the Flower Moon Audiobook (MP3 Download)

  • Haunting true-life murder mystery from David Grann.
  • Explores the Osage Nation's tragic history.
  • Uncovers the chilling conspiracy behind the murders.
  • National Book Award finalist and bestseller.
  • Features a gripping narrative of investigation.
  • Includes a major motion picture adaptation.
  • Delves into early FBI history and challenges.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.75
10

Devil in White City: Murder and Madness (Paperback)

  • True crime story set at 1893 World's Fair.
  • Combines history with thrilling storytelling elements.
  • Features infamous serial killer Henry H. Holmes.
  • Highlights architect Daniel Hudson Burnham's remarkable achievements.
  • Explores the allure of the Gilded Age.
  • A rich narrative with real-life characters included.
  • National bestseller and award finalist recognition.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $8.99
11

Killers of the Flower Moon: Osage Murders

  • #1 New York Times Bestseller
  • True-life murder mystery of the Osage Nation
  • Explores one of America's most monstrous crimes
  • Nominated for the National Book Award
  • Now a Martin Scorsese film adaptation
  • Engaging narrative and literary journalism
  • Uncovers chilling historical conspiracy and corruption
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $8.86
12

The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck, Mutiny, Murder

  • Page-turning narrative of survival and betrayal.
  • Explores themes of empire and human behavior.
  • Based on true events from 1740 shipwreck.
  • Intense court martial reveals shocking truths.
  • Acclaimed by The New York Times and others.
  • Thrilling account of mutiny and anarchy.
  • Written by bestselling author David Grann.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $14.99
13

If You Tell: Sisterhood and Secrets

  • True crime story of survival and resilience.
  • Focuses on three sisters' harrowing experiences.
  • Written by bestselling author Gregg Olsen.
  • Explores themes of abuse and family secrets.
  • Highlights the bond of sisterhood in adversity.
  • Details their journey towards freedom and justice.
  • A gripping tale of courage and empowerment.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $14.12
14

Amish Wife: Secrets, Lies, and Conspiracy

  • True crime investigation into a shocking Amish murder
  • Unraveling decades of secrets and conspiracies
  • Author Gregg Olsen reveals hidden truths
  • Covers Ida Stutzman's tragic death in 1977
  • Explores Eli Stutzman's questionable narratives
  • Includes testimonies from aging witnesses
  • Discovers long-buried letters revealing crucial evidence
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $4.99
15

Say Nothing: A Gripping Tale of Murder in Ireland

  • Explores notorious Jean McConville murder case.
  • Meticulously reported narrative of Northern Ireland's Troubles.
  • Winner of National Book Critics Circle Award.
  • Best-selling true crime and historical nonfiction.
  • Praises from major publications and critics alike.
  • Interviews reveal deep societal impacts of violence.
  • Now an FX limited series on Hulu.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $14.00
16

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

  • NATIONAL BESTSELLER and true crime classic.
  • Explores a chilling real-life murder case.
  • Written by acclaimed author Truman Capote.
  • Combines gripping suspense with deep empathy.
  • Revolutionary non-fiction narrative style.
  • Examines the nature of American violence.
  • Enduring impact on literature and true crime genre.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.00
17

Midnight Garden: Captivating Audio Experience CD

  • Engaging portrait of Savannah's Southern charm.
  • True crime entwined with Southern culture and intrigue.
  • Masterfully written by John Berendt, a modern classic.
  • Remarkable characters breathe life into the narrative.
  • Suspenseful story with unexpected twists and turns.
  • Evocative descriptions of Savannah's haunting beauty.
  • Captivating audio experience for true crime enthusiasts.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.73
18

Confessions of a Cartel Hit Man (Audiobook)

  • True story of a remorseful cartel hit man.
  • Martin Corona's rise in Southern California gang world.
  • Worked for Mexico's most feared drug cartel.
  • Crossed borders to execute dangerous assignments.
  • Key witness in cartel's downfall after arrest.
  • Seeks forgiveness and made peace with past.
  • A cautionary tale of redemption and remorse.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.75
19

Framed: True Stories of Wrongful Convictions (Paperback)

  • Explores ten harrowing true wrongful conviction stories.
  • Written by bestselling author John Grisham.
  • Highlights issues in the criminal justice system.
  • Co-authored with Jim McCloskey, innocence movement pioneer.
  • Impeccably researched with gripping suspense throughout.
  • Exposes racism and misconduct in court proceedings.
  • Shows the struggle for exoneration and freedom.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $16.15
20

In Cold Blood Audiobook [Digital Edition]

  • NATIONAL BESTSELLER true crime masterpiece.
  • Explores the Clutter family murder case.
  • Captivating narrative with deep emotional insights.
  • First non-fiction novel of its kind.
  • Reveals the complexities of American violence.
  • Written by acclaimed author Truman Capote.
  • A haunting tale of tragedy and justice.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $17.72
21

Chaos: Manson, CIA, and Sixties Secrets

  • NEW YORK TIMES BESTSELLER
  • Now a Netflix documentary
  • Uncovers FBI's involvement in Manson case
  • Reveals shocking evidence and cover-ups
  • Explores Manson's ties to Hollywood
  • Analyzes the sixties cultural paranoia
  • Two decades of investigative reporting
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.99
22

Savannah Secrets: A Midnight Garden Tale (Paperback)

  • Engaging true-crime narrative set in Savannah.
  • 30th Anniversary Edition with new afterword.
  • Vivid portrayal of Southern city life.
  • Remarkable cast of unique characters.
  • Suspenseful story with unexpected twists.
  • Combines humor and tragedy seamlessly.
  • Modern classic of nonfiction literature.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.09
23

Blood in the Water: Family Tragedy Unveiled (Paperback)

  • True crime narrative of greed and revenge.
  • Compelling story set on the high seas.
  • Mysterious family dynamics unfold in tragedy.
  • Suspenseful account of a fishing trip gone wrong.
  • Questions arise about a missing mother’s fate.
  • Explores wealth and betrayal within a family.
  • Gripping read for true crime enthusiasts.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $25.19
24

Mindhunter: Inside the FBI's Serial Crime Unit

  • Insights from FBI's elite serial crime unit.
  • Includes bonus material from renowned authors.
  • Explores psychological profiling of notorious criminals.
  • Features chilling real-life criminal cases.
  • Base for the acclaimed Netflix original series.
  • Authored by legendary agent John E. Douglas.
  • Dive into the minds of serial killers.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $19.68
25

Incident at Big Sky: Montana Killers

  • True story of abduction and manhunt in Montana.
  • Features biathlete Kari Swenson's terrifying kidnapping saga.
  • Engaging narrative by former sheriff Johnny France.
  • Intense showdown with notorious survivalist kidnappers.
  • Five-month search through rugged Montana wilderness.
  • Acclaimed by The New York Times Book Review.
  • A gripping tale of courage and survival.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $8.99
26

The Wager: A Tale of Shipwreck and Mutiny

  • Engaging tale of survival and mutiny.
  • Based on true events from 1742 shipwreck.
  • Explores themes of empire and human behavior.
  • Reveals shocking truth through court martial investigation.
  • Acclaimed by The New York Times and others.
  • Written by bestselling author David Grann.
  • Combines history with thrilling narrative elements.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $18.00
27

Framed: True Stories of Wrongful Convictions

  • #1 New York Times Bestseller
  • Ten harrowing true stories of wrongful convictions
  • Co-authored by John Grisham and Jim McCloskey
  • Explores injustices in the criminal justice system
  • Highlights factors leading to wrongful convictions
  • Impeccably researched with gripping narratives
  • Reveals the fight for exoneration and justice
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $14.99
28

Blood in the Water: Family Tragedy Unveiled (eBook)

  • Compelling true crime narrative of family betrayal.
  • Intriguing tale of greed and suspicion unfolds.
  • High-stakes drama set against a wealthy backdrop.
  • Rescue raises questions about a mother's fate.
  • Complex family dynamics keep you guessing till end.
  • Explores themes of power, money, and tragedy.
  • Gripping read for true crime enthusiasts.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.99
29

Deadly Women: 20 Shocking Cases of Killers

  • 20 chilling true crime cases of women who kill.
  • Uncover shocking stories of betrayal and revenge.
  • Includes infamous cases like Taylor Schabusiness.
  • Explores dark motives behind deadly actions.
  • Gripping narratives that will leave you stunned.
  • Part of the acclaimed Deadly Women series.
  • Perfect for true crime enthusiasts and casual readers.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $3.99
30

American Predator: The Hunt for a 21st Century Serial Killer

  • Explores Israel Keyes, a notorious serial killer.
  • Award-winning book with critical acclaim and recognition.
  • Investigates the FBI's pursuit of Keyes.
  • Highlights chilling details of his crimes.
  • Offers insights into a killer's psyche.
  • Combines extensive research and interviews.
  • A gripping narrative that's hard to put down.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.75