Top Craft Cocktail Bitters and Mixers

The best Cocktail Bitters includes Strongwater Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer (32 Servings), Amenazel Organic Soursop Bitters [16 fl oz], Bittermilk Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mixer and many others as mentioned below.

1

Strongwater Old Fashioned Cocktail Mixer (32 Servings)

  • Crafted for the perfect Old Fashioned cocktail.
  • Makes 32 servings for entertaining guests easily.
  • Features organic cherries and orange zest flavors.
  • Handcrafted with spices for a rich taste.
  • No alcohol, non-GMO, and gluten-free mix.
  • Mix with whiskey, bourbon, or rye spirits.
  • Award finalist recognized for quality and flavor.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $23.95
2

Amenazel Organic Soursop Bitters [16 fl oz]

  • Organic Soursop Bitters for natural constipation relief.
  • Blended with 21 beneficial herbs and roots.
  • Sweetened with honey for mild flavor.
  • Gentle colon cleansing without discomfort.
  • Inspired by traditional herbal remedies.
  • Free from gluten and artificial additives.
  • Crafted for optimum health benefits.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $32.99
3

Bittermilk Bourbon Barrel Aged Old Fashioned Mixer

  • Handcrafted by expert bartenders for authentic flavor.
  • Aged in Willett bourbon barrels for added complexity.
  • Mixes easily with bourbon, rye, or dark spirits.
  • Winner of multiple prestigious beverage awards.
  • Makes 17+ cocktails with simple ratio.
  • No artificial ingredients, all-natural components.
  • Perfect for cocktails or mocktails at home.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $19.99
4

Fee Brothers West Indian Orange Bitters [5 fl oz]

  • Citrusy aroma of orange lollipops.
  • Sweet and bitter orange marmalade flavor.
  • Enhances cocktails like gin and tonics.
  • Perfect for sophisticated martinis and more.
  • Crafted in Rochester, New York, USA.
  • Gluten-free and vegan-friendly ingredients.
  • 5 fl oz bottle for easy mixing.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $11.70
5

FREE AF Mocktail Tasting Pack (6 cans)

  • Assorted mocktail flavors for a delightful surprise.
  • Non-alcoholic drinks mimic classic cocktail experiences.
  • Afterglow extract provides warmth without alcohol.
  • Low-calorie, vegan, and gluten-free ingredients.
  • Ready-to-drink from the can, no preparation needed.
  • Crafted in the USA, acclaimed in New Zealand.
  • Empowers mindful choices without sacrificing flavor.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $24.00
6

Essential Contraptions Old Fashioned Bitters Set

  • Includes classic Angostura and unique pimento bitters.
  • Perfect for crafting Old Fashioned cocktails at home.
  • Explore diverse cocktail recipes with included recipe card.
  • An ideal gift for cocktail enthusiasts and beginners.
  • Adds depth to whiskey-based drinks effortlessly.
  • Four premium bitters in an elegant gift box.
  • Experience two centuries of bitters craftsmanship.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.99
7

Fee Brothers Black Walnut Bitters [5 fl oz]

  • Rich black walnut flavor enhances cocktails.
  • Aromatic mixer for creative drink recipes.
  • Gluten-free and vegan-friendly ingredients.
  • Perfect for desserts and culinary applications.
  • Expertly crafted by Fee Brothers mixologists.
  • Convenient 5 fl oz bottle for easy use.
  • Elevate your beverage experience with unique complexity.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $11.19
8

Mira’s Harvest Soursop Bitters (16oz)

  • Robust and potent flavor for wellness benefits.
  • Premium grade ingredients for optimal health support.
  • Unique blend includes rare African mahogany bark.
  • Daily use enhances overall vitality and well-being.
  • Farm-to-bottle freshness from sustainable Jamaican farms.
  • Trusted brand focused on quality and satisfaction.
  • Celebrate centuries of wellness traditions in every drop.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $29.97
9

HERBOGANIC Soursop Bitters Liquid [16 OZ]

  • Made with organic soursop leaves and fruit.
  • Supports overall wellness and vitality.
  • No artificial flavors or colors added.
  • Vegan, gluten-free, and non-GMO formula.
  • Easy to incorporate into drinks and cocktails.
  • Wildcrafted for maximum potency and quality.
  • Contains beneficial herbs for enhanced health.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $28.99
10

Strongwater Cocktail Bitters Sampler Set [6 Bottles]

  • Handcrafted bitters for unique cocktail experiences.
  • Six flavorful varieties in one sampler set.
  • Made with real, premium ingredients for quality taste.
  • Non-GMO, gluten-free, and no added sugar.
  • Small batch production in the Rocky Mountains.
  • Each bottle contains 0.5 fl oz of bitters.
  • Contains nuts; handle with caution.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $27.95
11

Fee Brothers Aztec Chocolate Bitters [5oz]

  • Delicious chocolate flavor with spicy undertones.
  • Ideal for enhancing dark spirits like rum.
  • Perfect for craft cocktails and mixology enthusiasts.
  • 5 oz bottle, convenient for home bar use.
  • Ships in Certified Frustration-Free Packaging.
  • A versatile ingredient for unique beverage creations.
  • Elevate your drinks with rich, complex flavors.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $12.37
12

PROOF SYRUP Old Fashioned Cocktail Mix [16oz]

  • Crafted with real bitters and cane sugar.
  • Perfect for authentic Old Fashioned cocktails.
  • Handcrafted for exceptional quality and flavor.
  • Easy to mix with your favorite spirits.
  • Suitable for cocktails and mocktails alike.
  • Generous 16oz size for multiple servings.
  • Ideal for parties and gatherings at home.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $39.95
13

PEYCHAUD'S Aromatic Cocktail Bitters (5oz)

  • Woodsy flavor with hints of licorice and caramel.
  • Perfect for classic cocktails like Manhattans.
  • Original bitters since the 1800s, timeless taste.
  • Crafted in New Orleans with unique ingredients.
  • Enhances drinks without overpowering their flavors.
  • Gold medal winner, recognized for quality.
  • Unchanged original formula ensures consistent taste.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.84
14

KAIZEN8 Fee Foam - Non-Egg Drink Alternative

  • Easy drink preparation with just a few drops.
  • No messy egg whites required for frothy drinks.
  • Neutral taste complements any beverage without interference.
  • Perfect for those avoiding eggs and egg products.
  • Creates a foamy finish for shaken drinks effortlessly.
  • Convenient four-pack for your drink-making needs.
  • Elevates your cocktails and beverages with a professional touch.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $27.95
  • Color: Clear
  • Material: Glass
15

Cocktail Crate Old Fashioned Mixer [3 Pack]

  • Award-winning old fashioned cocktail mixer.
  • Makes up to 51 cocktails effortlessly.
  • Crafted with aromatic bitters and demerara sugar.
  • Handmade from all-natural, fresh ingredients.
  • Perfectly pairs with aged spirits like bourbon.
  • Easy to use: pour, mix, and enjoy!
  • Top-rated brand for whiskey cocktail mixers.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $23.51
16

Essential Contraptions Orange Cocktail Bitters [4FL OZ]

  • One 4 FL OZ bottle of essential bitters.
  • Crafted from premium, high-quality ingredients.
  • Enhances cocktails, desserts, and savory dishes.
  • Perfect for home bars and professional mixology.
  • Versatile flavor enhancer for various beverages.
  • Rich history dating back to 1824.
  • Elevate your cocktail experience with unique flavors.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.87
17

Regan's Orange Bitters [10 oz]

  • 10 oz bottle of premium orange bitters.
  • Delicate orange flavor with spicy cinnamon notes.
  • Perfect for crafting classic cocktails like Manhattans.
  • 45% alcohol by volume for intense flavor.
  • Expertly developed by cocktail connoisseur Gary Regan.
  • Compact size: 2-1/4 by 2-1/4 by 8-1/4 inches.
  • Enhances a wide variety of mixed drinks.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $14.21
18

Peychaud's Aromatic Bitters [10 oz]

  • Authentic Peychaud's bitters for cocktail enthusiasts.
  • Perfect for classic cocktails like Sazerac.
  • Enhances flavors in culinary recipes and dishes.
  • 10-ounce bottle for convenient use and storage.
  • Rich history dating back to the 1830s.
  • Zesty flavor profile adds depth to beverages.
  • Gluten-free and crafted with quality ingredients.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $8.58
19

Angostura Aromatic Bitters [Pack of 2]

  • Classic aromatic bitters for cocktails and culinary creations.
  • Sodium and gluten-free for dietary needs.
  • Kosher certified, suitable for various diets.
  • Calms acidity in citrus for sensitive stomachs.
  • 100% vegan ingredients for ethical consumption.
  • Perfect for enhancing flavors in beverages and dishes.
  • Comes in a convenient pack of two 4 oz bottles.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $24.80
20

Fee Brothers Cherry Cocktail Bitters [5 fl oz]

  • Enhances cocktails with strong cherry flavor.
  • Perfect for classic and innovative drinks.
  • Use 1-3 dashes for optimal taste.
  • Gluten-free, vegan-friendly, and kosher certified.
  • Family-owned since 1864, five generations strong.
  • Includes a range of bitters and mixers.
  • Adds depth and complexity to beverages.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $10.97
21

Barsmith Old Fashioned Mix [12.7 oz]

  • Crafted for perfect Old Fashioned cocktails.
  • Distinctive blend of cherry, citrus, and bitters.
  • 12.7 oz glass bottle for convenient use.
  • Elevate home mixology with bar-quality flavor.
  • Easy-to-follow recipe included on the label.
  • Great balance without overpowering your whiskey.
  • Perfect for gifting or personal enjoyment.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $8.46
22

Essential Contraptions Angostura Bitters (Pack of 2)

  • Pack of 2, 4 FL OZ bottles each.
  • Number one selling bitters brand worldwide.
  • Premium ingredients for exceptional cocktail flavor.
  • Must-have for home and professional bars.
  • Enhances cocktails with rich complexity.
  • Perfect for a variety of beverages and dishes.
  • Two centuries of expertise in flavor enhancement.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: 0
23

Fee Brothers Cardamom Bitters [5 fl oz]

  • Essential for vintage Pre-Prohibition cocktails.
  • Adds depth and complexity to drinks.
  • Perfect for classic cocktails like old fashioned.
  • Use 1-3 dashes for optimal flavor.
  • Gluten-free, vegan-friendly, and kosher certified.
  • Family-owned since 1864, five generations strong.
  • Wide range of bar essentials available.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.98
24

Angostura Aromatic Bitters [2-Pack]

  • Highly concentrated flavor for cocktails and beverages.
  • Perfect for classic drinks like Manhattans and mojitos.
  • Adds complexity to fruity cocktails and mixed drinks.
  • Ideal for whiskey and rum-based beverages.
  • A versatile must-have for home bars and kitchens.
  • Pack of 2 for double the flavor enjoyment.
  • Renowned worldwide for enhancing culinary creations.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $72.99
25

Woodford Reserve Spiced Cherry Bitters (59ml)

  • Crafted with premium bourbon barrel aged spices.
  • Perfect for enhancing cocktails and beverages.
  • Distinct spiced cherry flavor profile.
  • Convenient 59ml bottle for easy pouring.
  • Great addition to any cocktail enthusiast's collection.
  • Elevate your drinks with sophisticated bitters.
  • Ideal for home bartenders and mixologists.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $12.00
26

Scrappy's Bitters - Fire Tincture [5 oz]

  • Crafted with organic ingredients for pure flavor.
  • Features habanero heat balanced by floral notes.
  • Use sparingly; extremely spicy for adventurous palates.
  • Hand-selected herbs and zests enhance quality.
  • No artificial flavors, chemicals, or dyes included.
  • Meticulously inspected and batch numbered for consistency.
  • Featured on Top Chef and Food Network.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $20.21
27

Fee Brothers Toasted Almond Bitters [5 fl oz]

  • Toasted almond flavor with a bitter edge.
  • Perfect for tropical cocktails and amaretto beverages.
  • Adds depth and complexity to classic cocktails.
  • Use 1-3 dashes for enhanced flavor.
  • Kosher, gluten-free, and vegan-friendly ingredients.
  • Family-owned since 1864, five generations of expertise.
  • Wide range of bitters and cocktail mixers available.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $11.19