Top Amish Romance Novels and Stories

The best Amish Romance includes An English Daughter's Return: Amish Love, Peacemaker: A Mifflin County Mystery [Book 2], Miss Fannie's Biscuits: An Amish Mystery and many others as mentioned below.

1

An English Daughter's Return: Amish Love

  • Pregnant woman seeks refuge in Amish country.
  • Tension between English and Amish cultures unfolds.
  • Romantic connection develops against societal judgments.
  • Complex family dynamics and past secrets emerge.
  • Journey of forgiveness and finding true belonging.
  • Heartfelt story of courage and acceptance.
  • Explores love in a traditional Amish setting.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $2.99
2

Peacemaker: A Mifflin County Mystery [Book 2]

  • Engaging sequel in the Mifflin County Mystery series.
  • Ada struggles with Rosa's unresolved disappearance.
  • Community tensions rise over accusations against Ephraim.
  • Secrets threaten to destroy friendships and love.
  • Arson reveals hidden truths in the tight-knit community.
  • Will love endure amidst suspicion and betrayal?
  • A captivating blend of mystery and romance awaits.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.99
3

Miss Fannie's Biscuits: An Amish Mystery

  • Engaging cozy mystery set in Amish country.
  • Baking contest backdrop creates thrilling suspense.
  • Follow Fannie Miller as she solves mysteries.
  • Collaboration of bestselling author Wanda E. Brunstetter.
  • Intriguing characters add depth to the storyline.
  • Explore themes of friendship and competition.
  • Perfect for fans of cozy mysteries.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $11.99
4

An Amish Home: A Collection of Four Heartwarming Stories

  • Collection of four heartwarming Amish novellas.
  • Stories by best-selling authors in the genre.
  • Explores themes of love, hope, and resilience.
  • Characters face life challenges and personal growth.
  • Captivating tales that celebrate Amish traditions.
  • Perfect for fans of inspirational fiction.
  • Ideal gift for audiobook listeners seeking comfort.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $7.99
5

Amish Sheltered Baby Ruth Price [eBook]

  • Susie's journey of healing after tragic loss.
  • Foundling baby brings hope and purpose to Susie.
  • Mark Stoltzfus helps Susie face her challenges.
  • Secrets threaten their budding relationship and trust.
  • A story of faith, community, and love.
  • Suspenseful twists keep readers engaged throughout.
  • A heartwarming second chance at love awaits.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $0.99
6

Amish Spring Blooms: A Romance Novella

  • Spring brings new beginnings and fresh romance.
  • Lily tends her garden while healing from heartbreak.
  • Josiah arrives with a secret mission to fulfill.
  • Hope blooms as connections deepen between them.
  • Will love conquer Josiah's troubled past?
  • A touching tale of faith and second chances.
  • Experience the warmth of Amish community and love.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $3.99
7

The Amish Quiltmaker's Unexpected Visitor

  • Engaging Amish romance with humor and heart.
  • Esther Kiem's matchmaking leads to unexpected connections.
  • Menno Eicher seeks a wife amidst family duties.
  • Joanna Yoder's bakery distracts Menno from his search.
  • Contrasting personalities spark romantic tension and growth.
  • Faith and love challenge their differences beautifully.
  • Perfect for fans of Amish romance novels.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $6.63
8

Hidden Amish Love [eBook] by Mary Lantz

  • An unrequited love story unfolds in Amish community.
  • Ester struggles with her feelings for Isaiah.
  • Rumspringa brings unexpected romance with Jacob Mast.
  • Isiah faces heartbreak with Sarah's deceitful intentions.
  • Secrets and lies complicate Ester's choices and future.
  • A shocking revelation challenges their relationships and trust.
  • Discover faith and love in this wholesome narrative.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $0.99
9

The Protector: Mifflin County Mystery

  • Mysterious disappearance of Rosa Petersheim shakes family.
  • Norman struggles with guilt as her protector.
  • Salina's love for Norman faces growing tension.
  • Intense search for Rosa unfolds in Big Valley.
  • Explores themes of faith, love, and loss.
  • Set in the captivating Amish community.
  • First book in the Mifflin County Mysteries series.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $11.99
10

Unlikely Amish Inheritance: Uplifting Romance Novel

  • Amish inheritance leads to unexpected love journey.
  • Englisch police officer returns to family farm.
  • Riddles reveal deeper connections and emotions.
  • Collaboration with Amish bachelor reignites old feelings.
  • Struggles between duty and love challenge characters.
  • Inspirational themes of faith and forgiveness explored.
  • From Love Inspired: uplifting romance stories await.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $5.98
11

Englischer's Folly: Amish Quilting Circle 1

  • Heartfelt story of love and healing.
  • Naomi navigates heartbreak after her engagement ends.
  • Aunt Anna encourages joining the quilting circle.
  • Shy Aaron struggles with his feelings for Naomi.
  • Will Don's interest complicate Naomi’s heart?
  • Explore themes of community and friendship.
  • A touching journey towards everlasting love.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $0.99
12

The Pretender: Mifflin County Mystery #3

  • Mystery unfolds with Rosa's unexpected return.
  • Two years of silence shattered by a shocking reunion.
  • Rosa's choices lead to family turmoil and confusion.
  • Her father struggles to accept her new life.
  • Friendships tested as secrets come to light.
  • Can the Big Valley become home again?
  • A gripping tale of love, loss, and forgiveness.
  • Price Range: $16.99
13

Amish Marriage Pact: Romance Misfits eBook

  • Heartfelt romance set in the Amish community.
  • Struggles of love and loyalty explored deeply.
  • Kate faces heartbreak and unexpected choices.
  • New love interests challenge past relationships.
  • Standalone story, part of the Amish Misfits series.
  • Written by USA Today Bestselling author Samantha Price.
  • Engaging plot with relatable characters and emotions.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $6.99
14

Green Pastures: Amish Sisters' Redemption Story

  • Engaging Amish fiction about love and redemption.
  • Three sisters navigate faith and family struggles.
  • Tabitha's return challenges her community's traditions.
  • Amanda seeks love despite past hardships.
  • Rose confronts marriage's realities and expectations.
  • Inspirational tale of sisterhood and self-discovery.
  • Fans of Beverly Lewis will enjoy this story.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.37
15

Simple Amish Love Books (eBook)

  • Sweet Amish romance with suspenseful twists.
  • Annie Fisher's journey of love and faith.
  • Stalker threatens her newfound relationship.
  • Updated and revised edition for a fresh read.
  • Part of the captivating Simple Love series.
  • Perfect for fans of Christian Amish romance.
  • Engaging story that keeps you turning pages.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $3.99
16

Amish ABCs: B Is for Bonnet (Children's Book)

  • Continues the heartfelt Amish ABCs series.
  • Follows four siblings returning to their Amish roots.
  • Explores love and family amidst cultural differences.
  • Features engaging characters and uplifting relationships.
  • Jonny discovers love with cafe owner Treva Kramer.
  • Secrets and truths challenge their budding romance.
  • Perfect for fans of Amish fiction and heartfelt stories.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $13.46
17

Orchard by Beverly Lewis [Paperback Edition]

  • Heartwarming romance set in an Amish orchard.
  • Ellie faces family challenges during the Vietnam War.
  • Explores themes of love, duty, and faith.
  • Engaging characters navigating unexpected life changes.
  • Written by bestselling author Beverly Lewis.
  • Captivating story of resilience and courage.
  • Perfect for fans of inspirational fiction.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $7.49
18

Lizzie's Little Mouse: Amish Heart Volume 8

  • Heartwarming Amish romance and community dynamics.
  • Lizzie pursues her dream bakery against all odds.
  • Unravel mysteries threatening her bakery's success.
  • Supportive friends aid in overcoming challenges.
  • Discover unexpected love along the journey.
  • Faith and hope drive Lizzie's ambitions.
  • Part of the captivating Heart of the Amish series.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $13.98
19

The Hidden Life: Whinburg Township Amish Romance (Book 1)

  • Heartfelt Amish romance set in Whinburg Township.
  • Emma Stolzfus faces love and personal growth.
  • Engaging story of friendship and hidden desires.
  • Quilt symbolizes the bond among three friends.
  • First edition published by Hachette FaithWords.
  • Standalone novels with intertwined family themes.
  • Guaranteed happily ever after for readers.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $15.26
20

Amish ABCs: A Fun Alphabet Learning Book (Paperback)

  • Heartwarming story about faith and family.
  • Explores Amish and English cultural relationships.
  • Four siblings seeking to reinvent their lives.
  • Set in peaceful Holmes County, Ohio.
  • Martin's journey of love and self-discovery.
  • Engaging characters with relatable struggles.
  • Perfect for fans of inspirational fiction.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $10.88
21

Sisters by the Sea: A Novel by Wanda Brunstetter

  • Four Amish sisters embark on new adventures.
  • Set in a unique tropical community in Florida.
  • Heartwarming stories of love and faith.
  • Explore romance and self-discovery across four tales.
  • Beautifully crafted by bestselling Brunstetter authors.
  • Experience the charm of Sarasota's Amish life.
  • Perfect for fans of inspirational fiction.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $9.96
22

Amish Thanksgiving Romance: Recipes & Guide

  • A heartwarming Amish Thanksgiving romance story.
  • Includes delicious authentic Amish recipes.
  • Features a thoughtful reading group guide.
  • Explores themes of love and friendship.
  • Highlights the struggles of caregiving and responsibility.
  • Perfect for holiday reading and inspiration.
  • Written by a bestselling, award-winning author.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $12.99
23

A Place to Call Home: Amish Love

  • Mary seeks belonging in Amish community.
  • Struggles with anxiety and loneliness persist.
  • Runs a bakery in Lancaster, Pennsylvania.
  • Meets intriguing Steve at hymn singing.
  • Must care for her injured father.
  • Explores faith and personal identity challenges.
  • Written by Amish author Linda Byler.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $16.99
24

Miriam's Quilt (Apple Lake Amish Series, Book 3)

  • Heartfelt story of love and redemption.
  • USA Today Bestselling Author Jennifer Beckstrand.
  • Explores themes of family, trust, and forgiveness.
  • Engaging characters with rich backstories.
  • Amish culture vividly depicted and authentically portrayed.
  • Humor and romance woven throughout the narrative.
  • Readers rave about its emotional depth and impact.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $12.99
25

Threads of the Heart: Esther King eBook

  • Heartwarming story of love and loss.
  • Set in a close-knit Amish community.
  • Explores themes of faith and healing.
  • Features a quilting circle as a refuge.
  • Hannah's journey of self-discovery and resilience.
  • Romantic tension with two suitors.
  • Perfect for fans of clean romance.
  • Price Range: $0.99
26

C Is for Courting: Amish ABCs (Children's Book)

  • Heartwarming tale of love and self-discovery.
  • Features four siblings adapting to Amish life.
  • Beth faces challenges as a single mother.
  • Romance blossoms unexpectedly with Junior Lambright.
  • Explores faith and personal growth themes.
  • Simultaneous hardcover and paperback release available.
  • Perfect for fans of Amish fiction.
  • Price Range: $18.95
27

Green Pastures Amish Shepherds Hill eBook

  • Engaging story of three Amish sisters' journeys.
  • Tabitha's struggle to reintegrate into her community.
  • Amanda pursues love despite family challenges.
  • Rose grapples with marital expectations and beauty.
  • Explores themes of faith, love, and tradition.
  • Heartfelt portrayal of Amish life and choices.
  • Perfect for fans of Beverly Lewis and Cindy Woodsmall.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $11.99
28

Willow Springs Amish Mystery Trilogy [3 Novels]

  • Three gripping novels in one captivating volume.
  • Explores deep-rooted family secrets and forgiveness.
  • Intriguing Amish community settings and traditions.
  • Engaging characters facing personal and familial challenges.
  • Twists and turns that keep you guessing.
  • Touching themes of faith and redemption throughout.
  • A must-read for mystery and drama lovers.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $18.21
29

Savannah's Amish Ties That Bind [Book]

  • A gripping story of faith and resilience.
  • Explores hidden Amish connections and family legacies.
  • Journey from Charleston to Northwestern Pennsylvania.
  • Challenges of love across cultural divides.
  • Inspirational themes of hope and reconciliation.
  • Part of The Amish Women of Lawrence County series.
  • Perfect for fans of spiritual women's fiction.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $14.99
30

Matters of the Heart: Amish Calling (Paperback)

  • Heartwarming story of love and family challenges.
  • Declan is a charming, funny community auctioneer.
  • Bethel is a dedicated caregiver for her siblings.
  • Compelling struggle with personal and familial responsibilities.
  • Romantic tension between childhood friends reignited.
  • Faith plays a crucial role in their journey.
  • Touching exploration of hope amidst adversity.
  • Average Rating out of 5:
  • Price Range: $8.92